The Uncanny, Part 2 : Contemporary Approaches

Tiana Razaiarinoro

Psychologue clinicienne, j’accompagne les transitions de vie qui transforment qui l’on est 🪷

·10 November 2026 7 min read
In the previous article, we saw that Freud (1919) proposed the first conceptualization of the uncanny. According to him, it is an incongruous experience, a sense of dissonance, or a vague feeling that something familiar suddenly becomes strange.

Subsequent authors have expanded on this line of thought by examining the conditions under which familiar boundaries become less clear: the boundaries between the self and the other, between the inside and the outside, and between what we know and what eludes us.

The uncanny cannot always be reduced to a forgotten memory resurfacing. It can also arise when an experience undermines our usual points of reference.

Imagine that you’ve always been considered the level-headed one in your circle of friends and family. You’re the one who reassures others, organizes things, takes care of others, and keeps a cool head. This role is familiar to you. It even shapes how you define yourself. Then, one day, you feel a rage you’ve never experienced before. Its intensity takes you by surprise. You don’t recognize yourself in your reaction, and yet it is yours. What troubles you is not just your anger. It may also be the encounter with a facet of yourself that doesn’t match the image you had built of yourself.

This situation isn’t automatically an experience of the uncanny in Freud’s sense. But it helps us understand one aspect of it: what unsettles us may be less the unknown itself than the discovery of something unknown within us.

When the Boundaries of the Self Become Uncertain

Psychoanalyst Michel de M’Uzan offers a particularly interesting perspective on this experience. According to him, the uncanny occurs when certain distinctions that we usually rely on to organize our experience begin to waver.

For example, we generally feel that the difference between the self and the other is obvious. We distinguish our inner world from external reality, our body from that of others, and our identity from what is foreign to us. These distinctions are essential to our sense of continuity. We don’t need to think about them constantly—they go without saying, so to speak.

But sometimes this sense of self-evidence crumbles momentarily.

Imagine running into someone you haven’t seen in fifteen years. They’ve changed, of course. But something in their gaze, their laugh, or their gestures immediately transports you back to a time in your life you thought was long gone. You experience two impressions simultaneously: this person is right in front of you, in the present, and yet part of you feels as though you’re facing someone from the past. It’s as if the present and the past were overlapping. What you perceive is no longer limited to the person standing before you. In fact, your own history also shapes this encounter.

Sometimes, the sense of disorientation can be even more personal. For example, you look at old photos and have trouble recognizing the person you used to be. You know it’s you, but you no longer feel fully connected to that former version of yourself. Who was that person? What remains of them within you? How can you be both that person from the past and the person you are today?

This isn’t necessarily a loss of identity. These questions may simply reveal that our sense of self is never as fixed as we might think. It is from this encounter with ourselves—when our usual points of reference are no longer enough to recognize us—that a sense of uncanny strangeness can arise.

The sensation of a foreign body

In his book *Phenomenology of Monstrous Bodies* (2006), philosopher Pierre Ancet explores how certain bodily experiences can also disrupt our perception of the familiar. Our body is generally the most familiar thing to us. We inhabit it without having to think about it every moment. In the mirror, we recognize our face, our gestures, our voice. Even when we are not entirely satisfied with it, we feel that it belongs to us. Yet this familiarity can be disrupted.

A person going through an illness, a major physical transformation, or a rapid bodily change may experience a sense of disconnection. For example, after childbirth, a new mother may recognize her body while feeling that it no longer quite belongs to her. A physical change can become unsettling when the sense of familiarity disappears. What destabilizes us isn’t necessarily a dramatic change. Sometimes it’s simply the fact that we can no longer find in our bodies the familiar markers that allowed us to spontaneously feel like ourselves. The body contributes to our sense of identity, our relationships with others, and the way we inhabit the world. And when this relationship changes, we may need time to come to terms with what is, after all, still a part of us.

The double, or the unsettling sensation of encountering oneself elsewhere

A double can take the form of a look-alike, someone who bears a striking resemblance to us, or another version of ourselves that we discover through the eyes of others. 

But the double is not merely a physical resemblance. We may also encounter our double in a person who shares our expressions, reactions, habits, or some of our contradictions. This closeness can reassure us, intrigue us, or, on the contrary, make us feel uncomfortable.

Indeed, the other person may reflect something of ourselves back to us, while still being a distinct individual. They resemble us without being us.

The double allows us to reflect on the connections between identity and otherness. Throughout our lives, we also shape ourselves through what resembles us and what sets us apart. And at certain points in our lives, this encounter can unsettle our sense of self or contribute to our personal growth.

Imagine that you recognize in a new coworker a way of communicating that you’ve always associated with your father. You know perfectly well that the two people are different. Yet certain gestures or intonations trigger an unexpected reaction in you. Your coworker isn’t your father. And the current situation isn’t the same as your childhood. And yet, something overlaps in your experience. This current encounter can stir up resonances that go beyond what you consciously perceive in the moment. This coworker is then no longer just a “new” coworker. He also becomes, momentarily, an unexpected mirror of our own history.

This experience isn’t necessarily unsettling in the psychoanalytic sense of the term. It can, however, prompt us to reflect on our own history and past relationships.

In conclusion: the uncanny can invite us to see things differently

From Freud’s early work to post-Freudian and contemporary reflections, the uncanny remains a rich concept for thinking about moments when the boundaries of our experience become less clear.

It can arise when a memory seems to take on an unexpected meaning, when our body feels different, when we encounter a double of ourselves, or when we discover a facet of our identity that we did not previously recognize. Strangeness does not necessarily refer to something we have forgotten. It can arise from an encounter with that which, within us or in the present, lies beyond the bounds of what is familiar to us.

And throughout our lives, we may be surprised by our reactions, bewildered by our emotions, or unsettled by the changes we’re going through. These experiences deserve to be met with attention, but without being systematically interpreted as signs of difficulty or turned into problems to be solved.

Getting to know oneself also means being open to encountering parts of ourselves that are not yet familiar to us. 


Bibliography

Blévis, M. (2024). The Uncanny: A Paradoxical Traumatic Experience? Les Lettres de la SPF, 47, 69–78.

Jozef Perelberg, R. (2013). The Uncanny: Triadicity and Temporality. Revue française de psychanalyse, 77(5), 1551–1558. 

Jung, J. (2015). “The Shadow of the Double: A Discomfort in Reflexivity.” *Child Psychiatry*, 58(1), 5–22.

Written by

Tiana Razaiarinoro

Psychologue clinicienne, j’accompagne les transitions de vie qui transforment qui l’on est 🪷

View profile

Read next